Page 1 of 1

Cutting off your penis doesn't mean you no longer have one

Posted: Tue Sep 14, 2010 9:20 pm
by SplitDik (imported)
Interesting article on a transsexual's journey towards penislessness.

http://www.thestranger.com/seattle/what ... ?oid=11184

What I Know Now About...

My Dick

by KATE BORNSTEIN

The Queer Issue

What I know About...: Coming Out by TRISHA READY

What I Know Now About...: My Dick by KATE BORNSTEIN

I thought I knew everything about dicks. Hey, I'd lived with mine for over 30 years, so you'd think I was well versed in the subject. But no, I found out there was a lot to bone up on... especially after I cut mine off. Whoops. Did I say "cut it off"? I didn't mean to. Well, yes, I meant to cut it off, but I didn't mean to say that I cut it off. Because for a long time after I'd cut off my dick, I maintained that I hadn't. Pardon my Zen, but first they cut off my dick; then they didn't; then they did. No, really.

How does that work? Well, one of the very first things I wanted to know from all the surgeons I interviewed was how they were going to cut it off. They explained that first they would slice my penis open lengthwise, then they'd scrape out the spongy stuff. Next, they would sew it up and pull it inside out, sort of like pulling a sock inside out by the toe. So the outside of my penis would become the walls of my vagina-to-be. Are you with me? Finally, they'd stuff the inside-out penis up inside me (don't worry, everybody's got a lot of flexible erotic tissue there, and it's very easy to make room for something like an inside-out sock). Et voilĂȘ! A new vagina! I paid my money, they did their magic, and that's how they cut off my dick.

I was very happy with the surgical explanation of my genital transformation. I was no longer a guy: I was woman, hear me roar! I started hanging out with a group of highly educated lesbian feminists in my then-hometown of Philadelphia. I wanted to know everything about this feminism stuff, and they wanted to know everything about why I considered myself to be a real woman. They were concerned about my phallus, which they defined as my male privilege and sense of entitlement. Well, I proudly told them how the doctors cut off my dick. I figured that would wash well with my new group of friends: I'd heard how many lesbian feminists wanted to castrate men, and here I was, having done exactly that! But no. None of this went down very well.

"You didn't cut off your dick at all," my lesbian feminist friends explained. "You simply turned it inside out and stuffed it up inside you." Aw, man!

I was crushed. Was I still a guy? No, not really. But I did stop calling myself a woman, and I began calling myself a transsexual lesbian. I hadn't really cut off my dick after all.

Years passed and I moved to San Francisco, where I hung out with a group of SM dykes known as the Outcasts. The Outcasts were an offshoot of the old Samois organization of SM lesbians; but the Outcasts included women who were bisexual and transsexual as well as lesbian. My sister Outcasts understood that I hadn't really cut off my dick, but we had a great time beating the hell out of each other anyway. Hey, we were the oddballs; and after six years of oddball life in San Francisco, I did what many San Francisco oddballs of the day did: I moved to Seattle. It was in Seattle that I discovered that I had, in actual fact, cut my dick off--bless the Seattle SM dykes.

See, I wanted to attend a Seattle-based SM dyke conference called PowerSurge, but they had a rule about tranny dykes: the dick-in-a-drawer rule. Any woman with a dick could attend PowerSurge, as long as she could take out her dick and slam a drawer on it. Hey, I could do that. Omigosh! Everything fell into place. I had cut my dick off after all!

Today? Oh, I still have a dick. I have several of them, in fact, in a cute little box by the side of my bed. They come in all sizes and shapes. I have a penis, sure, but it's an innie, not an outie. As for my phallus, well I'm still shaving bits of that sucker off every day of my life.

And that's what I've learned about dicks that I didn't know before they cut mine off.

Kate Bornstein is the author of Gender Outlaw and My Gender Workbook. Her new play, Strangers In Paradox, opens in San Francisco next spring. She really misses Seattle SM dykes.

Re: Cutting off your penis doesn't mean you no longer have one

Posted: Fri Sep 17, 2010 5:42 am
by Hash (imported)
Still have a penis? I guess you can look at it like that, but after the surgery, all that's left of the penis is the skin and a small portion of the glans, which is turned into or meant to be the clitoris. It's no longer a penis in my mind because it doesn't look, function, or ejaculate like a penis.

In actuality, a transsexual can never fully be a woman in the minds of women because they weren't born with a vagina, ovaries, uterus, etc., but that should be understood by the transsexual. They can look, sound, act, and be emotional like women, but they still might not be accepted by women. It's a sad situation, but this person has learned to adapt.

Re: Cutting off your penis doesn't mean you no longer have one

Posted: Fri Sep 17, 2010 12:18 pm
by devi (imported)
Not all women are born with vagina, working ovaries, uterus. There are the one-exers for starters.

Re: Cutting off your penis doesn't mean you no longer have one

Posted: Sat Sep 18, 2010 11:13 pm
by SplitDik (imported)
devi (imported) wrote: Fri Sep 17, 2010 12:18 pm Not all women are born with vagina, working ovaries, uterus. There are the one-exers for starters.

You don't have to convince us here, we understand this. But the article is about the fact that the general female public and even lesbians won't necessarily accept a transsexual as a woman. It also explores the fact that a transsexual may still have some "baggage" from being regarded as a male at some point previous in their lives, and that may need to be worked through.

I think the most important thing is never to define yourself based on other people. This is easier said than done, but is really important. As long as you depend on other people's love and/or acceptance, you will never be true to yourself.