I have a blog post called 'I want to abandon my family'. I'm at the point of simply saying I will let go of them. I returned from California Sunday where I had been visiting my brother. I felt rejected (he stated 'there is no support' for me and he found what I am doing 'bizarre' - sorry for the repeats here for those who have seen this). He also feels what I am doing is a choice. In a way that's very true but it's a choice I am making to be fully myself and happy.
I am starting to conciously let go of my family. I'm still open to hearing from them but the more time that passes with no word the more difficult it's likely to be to re-establish any kind of relationship. I'm really kidding myself here, anyway, there never was that much of a relationship.
My brother called my other brother's wife after I left him at the restaurant. He followed this up with an email the next day to her and copied me. The subject line was 'Thanks for the support'. Of course, this does not mean in and of itself that the rest of the family supports him and not me. OTOH, I haven't heard anything from my Dallas relatives to indicate otherwise, despite my two replies to his email.
If he had sent this only to me, I would not have responded. Since my sister-in-law received it, though, I wanted to respond to tell my side of things. I have to let go of the idea that if only I explain myself and what I'm going through better, the rest of the family will somehow understand. If they are ever to understand, they will have to reach that point on their own.
My second and final response was Monday morning. I haven't heard anything from anyone and in fact it's been several weeks since I sent my other brother and my sister-in-law a book named 'True Selves" to help families understand transsexualism and deal with their feelings. I never got an acknowledgement that they got the info on the book, which is very out of character.
If I think about this situation too long, it starts to tear me apart. Fortunately, I don't allow myself to remain in that spot for long.
I've pasted in here my final response to my brother's email. Feelings he was expressing were clearly not the result of a weekend visit gone bad. Clearly, he still has issues with me going back to my childhood. I mostly feel sorry for him now. A few times this week, I've felt guilty that I wasn't able to be the older brother he seems to have wanted. Those guilty feelings were short-lived.
I'm posting this simply because it helps me, still six days later, to get it out. The need to do this is lessening as the days go by.
I have changed names here, including my legal name.
MY SECOND RESPONSE (MONDAY MORNING):
You make assumptions that are not true about why I visited you, Thad. You also stated I showed no interest in your life at all. This wasn’t the case. I clearly stated we were both trying so I got that. I asked you if you were still flying and then why you weren’t, were you dating Susan (who is very nice) and I said it was good you were still friends after dating, how your job was going and I mentioned to you I remembered you had been concerned about the first day being stressful and then asked how that had gone. I discussed your job with you and if you thought you could straighten out the ‘fiasco’ situation there. Susan, you and I had a really nice conversation over dinner, at which I asked a lot about your work. When you mentioned the possibility of working for your old Bakersfield practice from Laguna Beach (remotely), I asked if you’d have to go back to working crazy hours. I said your house was beautiful and I’d met some of your nice neighbors. I said you were lucky to live in a beautiful spot. I talked to you about what kind of dog you would want to get when you brought that up, mentioned I’d noticed your books on dogs and suggested you might want to have someone come during the day to walk the dog since they don’t do well for long hours with no human contact. I asked why you needed a building permit for the kitchen and commented how beautifully it was done. I said I wished you had more palm trees. I am by nature introverted meaning I don’t tend to talk much. This is simply one way of relating to the world and there is nothing wrong with my being that way. I don’t see that your responses to my questions were any more in depth, or lively, than mine to you.
I appreciated your bringing the coffee and food to the table when we went for breakfast and other small things like that you did. I felt safe being in your home. I enjoyed walking around town with you and I told you it was fun.
I don’t feel at all that I dropped the gender issue out of the blue into your lap [note: this was in February]. Of course, it was sudden but how else could I have done this? I was only coming to fully understand and accept what was going on in my life in late December and January, after talking to the university therapist. We had two long phone conversations after that email and I thanked you profusely for calling. You say if I had brought this up sooner (when I didn’t know the whole thing clearly myself, as I said) you wouldn’t need the book implies that you’d be open to talking a lot about this major life change I’m going through. Or that you’d better understand thing, perhaps. Your response to Sue seems to say, though, that you don’t want me to talk much about it at all. Am I missing something here?? And to reiterate, talking about it with my family does not mean it makes up my entire life. It is indeed a huge life change, though, for anyone so you can bet I have to put a lot of thought and effort into it.
I was very anxious about visiting you because when we first spoke on the phone I apologized for any part I had played in making our relationship difficult. You responded with ‘I forgive you’, which is terrific. You did not acknowledge any part on your end, though, in problems. Whatever you feel or think, both parties in a relationship contribute to the good and the bad whether equally or not. So I never got the idea, rightly or wrongly, that you viewed yourself as having any part at all in what doesn’t work in our relationship.
I always wanted to be accepted by you but there always seems this identity stuff we can never agree on. So, yes, issues like being gay or transgender are on my mind when I see you. This in no way means my life is spent contemplating sexuality or gender. Do you honestly believe you can know, from a few conversations, what my life is like or how I spend my time? You have no clue as to how varied and rich my life is.
I’d also ask you to note that in my response here, I don’t attack who you are as a person, Thad, either now or in childhood. And if you think I don’t have issues there, you are dead wrong. I don’t criticize your choices or how you behave. I just don’t think it’s at all useful for me to bring these things up and part of that is because I realize my perceptions of who you are today are colored and off-balance because of past experiences that may be totally invalid today.
The name everyone else calls me by is indeed a way, and a healthy one, that I have distanced myself from a painful past. You’ve gone about handling the past your way and it would be really nice if you respected the way I’ve handled things, which also included forgiving our parents long ago. I felt fortunate in that I did that I forgave mom and dad years before they died and I was able to hug them and tell them I loved them, genuinely, in the last years of their lives. I clearly stated to you recently that all parents, including ours, do the best they can.
You do not know enough about my life, though, to make conclusions on how much time I spend thinking childhood issues. I am indeed thinking about childhood issues now in relation to gender therapy. That’s part of the process and helps me understand things about my life and who I am. These things from my past are not issues I’ve ever thought about before. It does not mean I’m sitting around bemoaning my childhood in any way. I moved on many years ago.
My hope in visiting you was that it would be the beginning of an improvement in our relationship. Things like this don’t happen over a weekend visit but it can be a start. I was feeling we were making a good start until we got to dinner Saturday. I just don’t see how things can improve, though, if I’m being told that my behavior is bizarre and I am not supported at all. I feel like I’ve been rejected by my family in a very painful way, and I’m talking about the present here, not the past. Saturday night I felt like I knew a little of what an older teen must feel like when he’s kicked out of the house for being who he is, whether it’s gay or transgender. What I don’t get here is how you think we can have a relationship if you don’t accept me. If you truly believe being transgender, or gay, is no more than a choice then that’s your reality and I’ll accept that and move on because…. It isn’t my reality and this difference in outlook is a roadblock, then, that we probably will never get beyond. I do care about you and wish you happiness but ultimately I have to look out for my own well-being and be true to who I am. Right now, and I really hope that will change, I don’t see that there’s room in your view of things to handle ‘who I am’. Ultimately, it would make me very happy if you become an important part of my life.
As I said last night,
Danya (imported) wrote: Mon Apr 21, 2008 8:39 pm
I’m always open to hearing from
you. I am not open, though, to having my character from childhood on criticized. I was very hurt by the way you treated me as a child but I see no point in bringing any details of that up. We were both children then, brother, and siblings often really don’t get along at all well. It’s irrelevant to me now.
Unless I’m being accepted for who I am, or at least know you’re making an effort to reach some understanding and acceptance, I will be unable to have a good relationship with you. That’s not at all the way I’d like things to be. Lack of acceptance and support is asking me to put aside who I am and pretend to be someone else so you will be comfortable. I can’t do that to myself.