Re: Sexual abused Dutch boys in RC boarding school castrated in the '50.
Posted: Tue Mar 20, 2012 6:40 pm
Twinsenboy, indeed stories about priests and church employees that abused children are showing up daily now, and in many countries, showing that it is a widespread and long standing practice. The catholic church will have to take real action, and not just move the culprits from their current jobs to other jobs, other places, or into seclusion.
Yesterday I read the complete abstract of the report done in the Netherlands. It's held in a quite detached, objective tone, and stresses that while the numbers of abuse cases is large, the percentage of children abused is still small, considering how many went through church institutions. It also exposes that child abuse is quite common outside the church too, but that inside the church it's twice as common. Interesting.
But what sets this story apart is not that 10,000 to 30,000 children were abused to varying extents by church people in Holland over several decades, but that several boys were castrated, apparently as covert punishment after they cried for help. This is what exceeds everything we are accustomed to see happen inside the church!
As far as I know, before these ones, the most recent cases of the catholic church getting involved in the castration of boys were at least 150 years ago, and weren't a punishment, but an "improvement", to keep them singing... And now these much more recent cases in Holland show up, with boys being castrated for reasons that are far less reasonable than the preservation of a high voice, however weak that musical reason might be!
As I understood it, the report avoided mentioning the castrations, limiting coverage to the more moderate cases of abuse, and the castrations were made public by a newsman rather than by the authors of the report. Now I'm waiting to see if additional cases show up, or if perhaps it turns out that the castrations weren't true at all. Let's wait and see.
There is one more thing: While I read quickly through the long abstract of the report, I think I saw that the commission learned about roughly 1700 cases of child abuse, and applied statistic methods to extrapolate this and arrive at an estimated total number of 10,000 to 30,000 cases. Under the same logic and methods, the 10 castration cases mentioned might be extrapolated to perhaps roughly 100? Or is that figure of ten cases already extrapolated from a single report of one case?
Given that this supposedly happened in the 1950s, many of the victims should still be alive and lucid. It would be interesting if they spoke up and told the world what really happened.
I will keep checking the news, as time allows.
Yesterday I read the complete abstract of the report done in the Netherlands. It's held in a quite detached, objective tone, and stresses that while the numbers of abuse cases is large, the percentage of children abused is still small, considering how many went through church institutions. It also exposes that child abuse is quite common outside the church too, but that inside the church it's twice as common. Interesting.
But what sets this story apart is not that 10,000 to 30,000 children were abused to varying extents by church people in Holland over several decades, but that several boys were castrated, apparently as covert punishment after they cried for help. This is what exceeds everything we are accustomed to see happen inside the church!
As far as I know, before these ones, the most recent cases of the catholic church getting involved in the castration of boys were at least 150 years ago, and weren't a punishment, but an "improvement", to keep them singing... And now these much more recent cases in Holland show up, with boys being castrated for reasons that are far less reasonable than the preservation of a high voice, however weak that musical reason might be!
As I understood it, the report avoided mentioning the castrations, limiting coverage to the more moderate cases of abuse, and the castrations were made public by a newsman rather than by the authors of the report. Now I'm waiting to see if additional cases show up, or if perhaps it turns out that the castrations weren't true at all. Let's wait and see.
There is one more thing: While I read quickly through the long abstract of the report, I think I saw that the commission learned about roughly 1700 cases of child abuse, and applied statistic methods to extrapolate this and arrive at an estimated total number of 10,000 to 30,000 cases. Under the same logic and methods, the 10 castration cases mentioned might be extrapolated to perhaps roughly 100? Or is that figure of ten cases already extrapolated from a single report of one case?
Given that this supposedly happened in the 1950s, many of the victims should still be alive and lucid. It would be interesting if they spoke up and told the world what really happened.
I will keep checking the news, as time allows.